I have the 10" ankle skinny in the Ink wash and I LOVE them - my favourite pair of skinny jeans yet! They fit really well, TTS, stretchy, but like cowgurl said, size down 1 in the cigarette leg (that style tends to fit big for some reason). I'm not sure about the 12" pencil leg, but I do recall trying them on and they fit more TTS than the 14" cigarette ones. They are great for tucking into jeans or wearing with ballet flats/heels. I like the plain back pockets as well. And the Ink wash is gorgeous, I get a lot of compliments when I wear mine

You should definitely try on a pair if you're interested in getting some so you know how they fit
