Brynk...The best way to go about this so that you do not get screwed is to file with paypal now...before you even re-send the item. That way the ball will be rolling with paypal. They will then ask you to send the item back to the seller and then you can provide shipping. He can not screw you if you have filed with paypal. The only way you could possible loose money is if he up and leaves, but paypal will probably back you anyways.
I sell under two names on ebay and ship over 200 items a week with both names...it can get really crazy if you do not file with paypal first. It takes a couple days for paypal to respond to the claim and even ask for your return confirmation number.
I really wish you the best of luck!!
I would be upset too if they are supposed to be one thing and they are another...!!!!
He really should have just refunded you the difference IMo...that is. As a seller of denim too...if I misrepresent something I have to take care of it however the customer needs it to be done, and if the customer needs a little compensation I am more than willing to do that.
This guy seems super rude...File with paypal then see how rude he is