i agree with both kile and mihalis- i think kile's new banner would be a lot better- since the main background of the forum isn't black, having a black-background banner that gets cut off makes no sense.
i also like the new "blog, mall, forum" buttons kile drew up, looks way better than the tired tabbed look (apple.com circa 2000).
also, since HF if free now, how about all us who paid to join when it wasn't get to throw out at least the top banner ads? Especially if we've been somewhat productive members of the forum for a while.
I propose if you've been a member for a year, and you originally paid the 10 bucks to join, you get bumped up to a pro member or at least get to throw out the banner ads. If extra inbox space is just too much storage cost, so be it.
And I have to wonder how expensive this stuff would be for dave in total- kile throws down mockups for shit all the time just as a free example that are 100x better than what Dave apparently pays like $500/Photoshop layer for. Why not just let someone like him make like 3 options for new banner/buttons/other design elements and have a poll? I'm not an expert in web design by any means, but how hard can it be to switch out a few pics? If the site is well-designed (i.e. built to evolve and change) i wouldn't think it would take more than like an hour.
$500? Really?