Don't say anything because I already ordered the Jils! I am looking for something pretty classic looking, and to me that says classic. It is a bit pointy to be old man classic, but I like the shape still! As for the bulbousness, the black one's picture was taken at a slight angle (you can see the lining in the top picture more) so that where I am assuming it comes from since it isn't present as much in the brown picture.
I don't have fat feet, and I would say they are probably pretty "average" (whatever that is) for my size. Looking at 3 especially, and possibly 4 hurts my toes. The brand seems to be a cheap Aldoesque throw away brand which I am trying to stay away from, but they do have nicely shaped more modern, less clunky shoes that I see everywhere in stores here at least.