Quote:
Originally Posted by avatar 
I will retract my comment that Carter's book is racist. However, it misrepresents historical facts for political reasons, and compares the government of Israel to the former government of South Africa.
|
The word 'apartheid' is a proper term for what is happening in the West Bank. Even Bishop Desmond Tutu said Israel is practicing apartheid in the West Bank.
Israel already has a majority of the land, much bigger than the mandate. They need to give the Palestinians the state (their offers have refused to give them even water rights).
They withdrew 7,000 people from Gaza. However, in the West Bank they are building a huge wall to annex more land. Furthermore, Israel continues to build settlements in the West Bank and control a majority of the land. These settlements are off limits to Palestinians and have their own separate systems while the Palestinians live in abject poverty. It _IS_ apartheid.
The United Nations considers Israel's repeated settlements (yes they continue to build them) in the West Bank as ILLEGAL. Israel has literally dozens of UN resolutions against them and their illegal settlements. Any votes to do anything are automatically veto'd by the USA.
Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, etc considers what Israel is doing in the West Bank as criminal.
Quote:
Originally Posted by avatar 
Israel has been in a war for their existence since 1948 - it offered peace many times, and the terrorists in charge of the PLO/PA refused. If they accepted the British Mandate's partition, they'd have a WAY bigger state than they ever have had a dream of.
|
The British Mandate split Palestine into a Jewish state and a Palestinian state. Jews, despite being an incredibly minority in the region would get a majority of the land. Furthermore, 49% of the Jewish state was to have a Palestinian 'minority.'
The Palestinian state would be overwhelmingly Palestinian, have a larger population, and be a smaller amount of the land.
Why on earth would you expect people to accept that? Would you expect the United States to accept an offer from outside country to split the land in half?
We hold a candle to Israel as some sort of "Champion of Democracy" in the region. So why are they constantly compared to "Backwards Arab neighbors?"
Peace could happen, as long as Israel continues to build _MORE_ settlements in the West Bank in hope of becoming a majority there, it's not going to happen.